Why the iPhone Timer App displays a Fake Time
While building my event timer app called stagetimer.io I came across a peculiarity with displaying time and found out that the iPhone timer addresses it by showing us a fake time. By definition, a countdown shows how much time is left. So if the countdown says 5s we assume there are 5 seconds left. But that’s not the whole truth.
The iPhone countdown timer doesn’t strictly display the correct time but adds 500ms, or half a second, to the remaining time. It does this to make the reading of time more intuitive for humans. The alarm at the end of the countdown is not affected by this 500ms inaccuracy.
Countdowns are tricky
Math.floor(milliseconds / 1000)
The timer jumps to 4s right when hitting start and once the timer switches to 0s there are still 1s to go. This makes a lot of sense when counting up, for example, 10:00 is displayed during the first minute of 10 AM, not 10:01, always rounding down. But for a countdown timer, this is counterintuitive. It is easier to understand if the timer has a fractional seconds display.
Now the timer displays 0.9s seconds instead of 0s to show clearly that there is still time left on the clock. However, I didn’t want to show fractional seconds for my timer.
Checking how the iPhone does it
Now I was curious how my iPhone solves this conundrum. So I set my iPhone timer to 5s:
After I click “Start” the iPhone timer shows 5s, not 4s like in the example above. But it switches to 4s before a full second expired. It then counts proper seconds until it reaches 0s which, again, is not a full second. And if you tap “Pause” just after it jumped to 0s it will promptly jump back to 1s to show you that there is, in fact, still some time left on the countdown.
I figured that the good folks at Apple add an extra fake 500ms to the actual time to start that countdown display at 5s instead of 4s. The timer ends and the phone beeps if the actual time hits 0s and the “fake” time hits 500ms. So they faced the same problem I did and came up with a practical solution. After all, if you start a 5s countdown, it should start at 5s right? For illustration, here is my simple timer doing the same trick.
So there you have it, the iPhone timer is technically lying a little bit to you.
Edit: About rounding time
Some have pointed out that the problem could be solved more easily by rounding to the nearest second or rounding up instead of rounding down. This is correct. Suppose we have
5459543ms that we want to bring into the traditional form
I first divided the number into hours, minutes, and seconds with the help of some modular arithmetic and applied the rounding afterward. Rounding down results in
01:30:59, which is correct, but rounding to the nearest integer or rounding up results in the impossible time
time = 5459543 seconds = (time / 1000) % 60 // 1.517 minutes = (time / 60000) % 60 // 30.992 hours = (time / 3600000) % 24 // 59.543
However, rounding the time to seconds first
5460000ms, and breaking it down afterward yields the same result as described above with adding 500ms, namely
time = 5460000 seconds = (time / 1000) % 60 // 0.000 minutes = (time / 60000) % 60 // 31.000 hours = (time / 3600000) % 24 // 1.517
Edit 2: In an earlier version I messed up my rounding as described. Many helpful, as well as helpful and insulting, comments pointed out my error. So in addition to learning about counting time I also learned how it feels to be wrong on the internet 😅